Boiler or gas water heater - which is better?

In the repair process, the issue of supplying housing with hot water is of particular relevance. For the most part, such a need arises due to the instability of hot water supply or the lack of the ability to connect it. It is in such situations that people are trying to decide if a boiler or gas water heater is better to buy? In this article we will try to find the answer to this question and consider the advantages and disadvantages of both devices.

to contents ↑

Types of household appliances for organizing hot water

Individual sources of hot water in apartments and houses are divided into two main varieties, which depend on the type of energy used:

• Geysers. Most people have the erroneous opinion that these devices are bulky and unattractive units. However, modern gas heaters can have compact dimensions and an attractive appearance that will not spoil the overall interior of your kitchen. Such units can be of two types - automatic and semi-automatic.
• A boiler is a storage water heater that can run on gas or electricity. Such a device consists of a thermally insulated capacious tank, a tubular heater and a mechanism for regulating the level of water heating.

Determining which gas column or electric heater is better is quite difficult, because each of the devices has its own advantages and disadvantages. Therefore, a decision should be made based on the needs of a particular premises.

to contents ↑

Advantages and disadvantages of geysers

Modern models of gas water heaters significantly differ from their predecessors in small dimensions and neat appearance, which allows you to place them in the room of any even the smallest-sized kitchen.

pros

In order to accurately understand for yourself, a boiler or a geyser - which is better, except for the dimensions, it is necessary to take into account no less significant advantages:

• the ability to provide an apartment or house with hot water for a long time;
• water heating almost immediately after opening the tap;
• modern turbocharged speakers are equipped with electronic control systems;
• reliability in operation;
• ease of repair in the event of a malfunction.

Important! Most modern equipment is equipped with an easy-to-use display, indicators for various purposes and a special thermometer.

Minuses

But like any water heater, a geyser, in addition to its positive qualities, has a number of disadvantages. You should not forget about them either, determining if the boiler or geyser is better.

The most important in this regard are:

• Installing a gas column in the house is quite a troublesome task. Before performing the installation, you will need to draw up a project and coordinate it with specialized services.
• Before embedding such a design, you will have to collect a whole folder of permits and get an official document that allows installation.
• For anyone using a gas heater, you will need to equip a reliable chimney and a supply and exhaust ventilation system.Although there are exceptions, as many manufacturers supply modern units with coaxial exhaust gas extraction, for which a separate flue circuit is not needed.
• To achieve stable and trouble-free operation, you will need constant pressure of gas and water in the system. Unfortunately, modern houses in most cases cannot boast of the stability of these indicators.
• The efficiency of its use of the gas column is somewhat inferior to the use of an electric boiler. The efficiency of a gas-based water heater is at most 92%, while the similar performance of electrical appliances is about 98-99%. This should also be taken into account when determining which is better - a gas water heater or an electric water heater.

Important! The final temperature of the water dispensed by the column directly depends on the state of the fluid entering the system. In many houses, in severe winter frosts, water enters the system too supercooled, and therefore even the most powerful installation will not be able to provide the owner with the required indicators.

to contents ↑

Advantages and disadvantages of electric boilers

The accumulative water heaters of electric type of food are very popular today.

pros

Such installations have a number of very significant positive qualities. In connection with them, many consumers give preference to just such devices, solving a problem, a boiler or a geyser - which is better.

Considering in more detail the advantages of electric boilers, one can note the following most significant factors:

• Simple and affordable installation, which can be done independently, without the approval and call of qualified specialists.
• Such systems do not require additional costs for the arrangement of the chimney and ventilation system.
• The operation of the boiler is independent of the temperature and pressure of the water in the central water supply system.
• High rate of intensity. The efficiency of such water heating devices is 98-99%.
• The boiler is able to provide a one-time consumption of a large amount of hot water.
• The heater of modern design of such a device does not directly contact with water, and therefore scale does not occur on its surface.

Minuses

But like any device, electric boiler systems have some disadvantages:

• One of the most important disadvantages of water heaters of this type is the limited amount of heated water, and accordingly - the need to wait for the next portion over a certain time period.
• Such designs have a sufficiently large size, as they must contain the required volume of water. This fact can be a significant drawback in small apartments.
• The price of boilers is usually slightly higher than for gas water heaters, which also does not contribute to budget savings.

to contents ↑

Stock footage

Buying specialized devices to provide domestic hot water, it is impossible to say that a gas water heater or a boiler is much better than alternative equipment. It is worth considering many of the most important factors in the form of the number of family members, the cost-effectiveness of the installation, the characteristics of the room and much more. We hope that the recommendations in this article will help you make the right choice and enjoy the amount of hot water you need for a long time.