Which vacuum cleaner is better - with a bag or with a container?

Which vacuum cleaner is better - with a bag or with a container? - Choosing a new assistant in the apartment, you will definitely come across this issue. The opinions of close people on this subject are divided, because everyone seeks to protect the model that he uses, often concealing its shortcomings. In this article you will find objective information that will help you choose a vacuum cleaner with a bag or container.

to contents ↑

Vacuum cleaner with dust bag. How to choose?

This model of a household appliance is not a novelty for today's people. Previously, such vacuum cleaners caused as many problems as they were useful, because the noise from his work could be heard in the neighboring apartment, and the removal of dust from the dust collector could often end in a torn bag. Modern models are much more convenient and practical to use.

The principle of operation of a vacuum cleaner with a dust collector

Dust and dirt that gets into the vacuum cleaner with an air stream remains in a special bag of breathable fabric or paper. Thus, the flow is filtered, debris remains in the bag, and purified air is thrown out through the outlet.

Important! Devices can have bags for disposable cleaning (made of paper or synthetics) or for reusable (made of fabric).

Consider the main advantages and disadvantages of units of this type in order to understand which vacuum cleaner is better - with a bag or with a container.

Advantages of a vacuum cleaner with a dust collector:

• Easy to operate. Using and cleaning with this model of dust-absorbing equipment is easy and simple. Even a schoolboy can cope with such a task.
• The vacuum cleaner does not require washing, cleaning and drying after each cleaning of the apartment.
• In many units, you can adjust the power, thereby adjusting the device for yourself and making cleaning easier.
• If you use disposable bags, then cleaning is greatly simplified and does not require additional effort.
• The ability to use a reusable dust bag in the absence of paper in the house.

Important! Filtration qualities are better with disposable paper bags. They trap up to 99.9% of dust, while fabric reusable bags filter out only large particles of dirt.

• Large selection of models with different performance characteristics.

Vacuum cleaner with a dust bag. Disadvantages:

• Always keep the waste bin full.

Important! From a large amount of dust in the bag, the power of the vacuum cleaner itself decreases. Accordingly, the quality of cleaning is deteriorating.

• Additional expenses for disposable dust collectors.
• Sometimes it is very difficult to pick up paper bags specifically for a given model. Universal may not be suitable, and dust collectors created specifically for this brand are not always on sale.
• Reusable waste bins in case of prolonged use may break and lose their dustproof properties.
• Paper bags can tear during cleaning, which can lead to damage to filters, engine, dust in the air.
• A difficult and unpleasant procedure for cleaning a fabric dust bag.

Important! Europeans, despite a number of shortcomings of a vacuum cleaner with a dust collector, still give preference to them - because of the simplicity of operation.It is worth noting that there are no problems with the purchase of disposable bags in developed countries.

Since the additional costs for waste bins and some of the problems associated with their purchase add to their difficulties, people increasingly prefer a vacuum cleaner with a container. Is such a purchase more profitable?

to contents ↑

How to choose a vacuum cleaner with a dust container?

Such devices have appeared on the household appliance market relatively recently. Many people consider vacuum cleaners without a dust bag to be more perfect and practical. But still, and these devices have their drawbacks.

The principle of operation of a vacuum cleaner without a dust bag

This technique works on the principle of a cyclone, which is why they are called "cyclone vacuum cleaners." In a swirling flow, air is sucked in, dust and debris settle on the walls of the container, which is divided into at least two sections:

• in the first - all large garbage is delayed;
• in the latter, the smallest dust particles.

Advantages of the cyclone vacuum cleaner:

• There is no constant need to purchase and replace replaceable trash bags.
• Removing trash from the container is very simple. This procedure does not take more than 2 seconds.
• Due to the fact that all the garbage in the container is sorted in two compartments, you can easily find small valuable things that “accidentally” got there. This is especially true for families where there are little children who constantly scatter small toys or hair bands on the floor. Opening the container, you will immediately notice the "loss".
• Filling the container does not affect the operation of the device.
• The cleaning process also makes it easier to keep the vacuum cleaner assembled.

The disadvantages of the cyclone unit:

• Fine dust, due to the fact that centrifugal force acts poorly on it, quickly clogs the filters that are placed in front of the container. Thus, the filter elements quickly become unusable.
• The disadvantage of some models is the accumulation of static electricity during its operation.
• Many devices do not have the ability to control power in their functionality. This feature is due to the poor response of the cyclone system to changes in the rate of air intake.
• Cleaning the container is a rather time-consuming process. It needs to be washed from time to time. Filters also require periodic cleaning.

Important! Ignoring such requirements will lead to a significant reduction in the quality of vacuuming.

• Plastic dust collector quickly loses its transparency and beautiful appearance, due to mechanical damage from large particles of debris.

to contents ↑

Vacuum cleaner with aquafilter

You can choose a vacuum cleaner with a dust container with an aquafilter. This model is a kind of cyclone aggregates. Let us dwell on the features of such a device. Polluted air passes through water, dust dissolves in it and is not thrown out.

Important! Water vacuum cleaners are considered more hygienic models. Especially people with allergies should appreciate them.

Advantages of the aqua vacuum cleaner:

• It does not require the purchase and regular replacement of garbage bags.
• Perfectly remove debris that dissolves in water from surfaces.
• Humidify and refresh the air in the room.
• Debris from the device is very easily removed. To do this, it is enough to pour dirty water and rinse the container.

Disadvantages of water devices:

• After each use, the appliance must be thoroughly washed and dried.

Important! Failure to comply with this rule may lead to the development of harmful microorganisms on the unit, as a result of which it will become a source of fungus in the apartment.

• When storing takes up a lot of space.
• Garbage that does not dissolve in water becomes a problem for the vacuum cleaner.
• In the case when the dust got inside the air bubble, it is not filtered and goes outside when the air bubble bursts.
• Vacuum this appliance carefully, avoiding sharp bends and turns. Otherwise, water may splash.
• The need for continuous monitoring of the water level in the container and, if necessary, topping it up.

Important! Sometimes this procedure has to be done even during cleaning.

to contents ↑

Which model to choose with a bag and a container?

Both species deserve attention and have their fans. But there are drawbacks, as you have already seen, also in all types of vacuum cleaners. In order to be satisfied with your choice in the future, you should give preference to well-known trusted manufacturers.

Consider the most popular vacuum cleaners with a bag and a container.

Overview of popular models of bag vacuum cleaners

In this category, according to technical experts and users, such models are the best.

Miele S 5481:

• The device is made in Germany.
• The power of the device is adjustable and reaches 450 watts.
• All standard nozzles are included. Turbo brush available separately.
• The case has three chassis rollers, each of which can be rotated 360 degrees. This makes the vacuum cleaner extremely manoeuvrable.
• All side surfaces of the vacuum cleaner are equipped with a rubber chipper.

Siemens VS 08G2490:

• German unit that works with a 6 liter disposable dust collector.
• It has in its design an Ultra HERA Active carbon filter, which eliminates not only dust, but also various odors.
• By means of a stepless regulator, the suction power of the device can be set. The maximum power value is 420 watts.
• The brush kit that comes with the vacuum cleaner also includes an Electromatic turbo brush.

Karcher VC 6350:

• Reliable and convenient device of German assembly in the appropriate quality class, which can be controlled remotely.
• A special Stand-by option puts the device into sleep mode if you need to take a break during cleaning. Starting the engine from this mode is more gentle for it than when the vacuum cleaner is completely turned off.
• A special feature is the ComfoGlide carpet nozzle, which has a star shape.
• The unique Quick-click nozzle locking system allows you to quickly attach the necessary brush with one click and holds it tightly.

Rowenta RO 4541 Silence force:

• The vacuum cleaner can work with a maximum power of 450 watts.
• Thanks to the special Silence-System technology, the robot of the device is almost silent.
• The device kit includes not only standard nozzles and a turbo brush, but also a “noiseless” delta-shaped nozzle.

Electrolux Z 7350:

• High-quality Swedish unit without special "bells and whistles".
• It has a standard set of brushes in its configuration, the filtering system is also no different from other bag devices.
• Particularly noteworthy is the dust collector made of S-BAG Long Performance synthetic material, the design of which contributes to the creation of low aerodynamic drag even in case of a large amount of accumulated debris.

Overview of the best container vacuum cleaners

The rating of this category of dust collectors can be determined in this way.

Panasonic MC-E8035:

• Compact device with a small power of 340 watts.
• The wheels and body, thanks to the rubber coating, do not leave scratches on the floor or on the furniture.
• The cost of the model is more than acceptable.

Daewoo RC-4008 B:

• Unit suction power 450 watts.
• Bactericidal dust collector - Silver Nano system.
• In case of a large amount of garbage, you can install a dust collector of paper on 4 liters.
• The body of the device has clamps for nozzles that come with the vacuum cleaner.
• The cost of the device, taking into account all the advantages of the unit, is truly funny.

Samsung SC8471:

• The device has a convenient control system, which is located on a telescopic tube.
• The set of nozzles, in addition to standard brushes, also includes an efficient Power PET Plus turbo brush, which perfectly copes with the removal of pet hair.

Bosch BSG 62085:

• The device is characterized by high maneuverability and hygienic cleaning of the container.
• The maximum power of the vacuum cleaner is 400 watts.
• The volume of the container is 1.2 liters, but also the device makes it possible to use a disposable paper bag of 3.3 liters during cleaning.

Electrolux ZCX 6205:

• This device will be a useful acquisition, especially for residents of large houses and apartments.
• The suction power is 300 watts. All power consumption is 1800 watts.
• The device’s electrical system is characterized by soft start technology, which protects the engine from sudden heavy load.

to contents ↑

Which is better to choose a vacuum cleaner - with a container or bag?

Having considered all the advantages and disadvantages of each model, it will be easier to decide for yourself which vacuum cleaner is better - with a bag or with a container.

If we leave the economic side of the issue, it is obvious that a device with a dust collector in the form of a plastic container is much more convenient to clean than devices with a garbage bag. This is explained by the presence of an exhaust air filtration system and the reliability of the engine, which is not afraid of a crowded container. In addition, there is no need to update supplies of disposable trash bags.

Important! There is also a vacuum cleaner with a bag and a container. Such devices are very convenient, because if damage has appeared on the plastic container, you will not have to wait with the cleaning until you buy a new one.

to contents ↑

Total

to contents ↑

Stock footage

In order not to miscalculate with the purchase of household appliances for cleaning the apartment, you should think in advance which vacuum cleaner with a bag or container will be more convenient for you. The information in this article will help you make the right choice and get a really useful assistant. Pay attention not only to the technical characteristics of the device, but also to its dimensions, because most of the time you will have to store it in a secluded place. It is also better to give preference to a well-known brand. It will be much easier to buy components and related products for them than in the case of a little-known manufacturer. And the build quality and plastic in such units will be guaranteed.